The answer of course is not cookie cutter. It depends on what sort of help you think you will need most as a startup (e.g. BD intros? Hiring help? Product feedback? Help raising the next round?).
In general, I think most investors fall into the following classes (and many angels are in multiple of these categories - as are most of the people mentioned below). A good financing round, especially if it includes multiple angels/investors would optimally have people representing more then just the below:
- Connectors. These people know a lot of people and typically used to work in sales or BD before becoming an angel. They can help a lot with intros or some advice on structuring a deal that will make or break a company. They are in the flow of information and deals and can provide you with competitive insights and early information on customers that is crucial to your success. Most top tier venture funds provide this function. Ron Conway and team are legendary for their span of network and the fact that they know everyone.
- Product People. These people are very smart on product and can give you specific advice on UI, viral loops, etc. Note: a lot of people claim they are good at product (i.e. everyone has an opinion) but I think the set of people who are very good at this is quite small. Roelof Botha and David King are two examples of people who have excellent product feedback.
- Tacticians & Builders. These are usually recent or current entrepreneurs or operators. They don't give you the banal high level advice about e.g. hiring ("always hire the best") that all your other angels will give you - they will actually make 10 intros to strong candidates and then give you the magic tip on how to close the top candidate. Most angels and investors are great at the high level strategy, but don't add much value here. This skill set is actually rarer then one would think and an important one.
- Smart Business People. How do you think about what you are doing as a business? How will you make money? What pricing schemes should you try? When should you turn on monetization at all? How do you build a brand for your company and what sort of marketing should you do?
- Domain Expert. This investor has worked in an operating/general management or product role in the industry you are looking at. They can give you industry specific tips, insights, customer intros and advice that would have taken you months to discover. They often decrease in value over time as you learn the industry and detail, but early on they can help enormously.
- The Brand. These angels don't add much value besides having a brand name. Best case it helps boost your funding announcement. Worst case they will have terrible advice delivered with enormous confidence. Make sure to vet people before adding them to your round.
- The Filler (AKA Dumb Money). You are trying to raise a $1 million convertible note and have $700K committed. You are exhausted with fund raising and want to just go back to building product, which is what you love to do. So you bring in folks who can write big checks that you don't expect to add much value. Obviously it is much better to bring in someone who can help out, but pragmatically it is good to have available capital to fill out the round if needed, as long as it is not from people who will actively decrease value. (by taking up your time with needless asks to meet up, refuse to sign documents needed to e.g. raise the next round etc. etc.)
DO YOUR DILIGENCE!
This title is in all caps on purpose. If your co-founder is equivalent to your husband/wife, this makes your board member your mother-in-law, and your other investors close relatives (cousins, uncles, etc.).
Just as the investor will do diligence on you, you will need to make sure other people the investor has invested in *love* that angel or VC. For the lead investor ask to talk to their references. For other investors do the same where possible. This is obviously time consuming, but whoever you bring on board will be helpful, or detract from the company, for potentially the lifetime of the company.
I will write another blog post later on doing diligence on investors...
Any types of investors I missed?